[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Front St.Clovis Schools Section - Clovis Free PressBack St.
Vol. 17  No. 21 Final Edition
Clovis Free Press
Teaching of Reading
Mixed Results on Open Court Text & K-3 Test Scores
By Amy Williams, Assoc. Editor

CLOVIS -- The California State School Board adopted a new textbook this year to help teachers teach reading. The State may have made a big mistake.

Open Court is a textbook series that uses a radical approach to teaching that has most members of the teaching profession concerned. To implement the Open Court text material in classes, teachers must follow a very inflexible lesson plan. Worse yet, every teacher in the school is held accountable for specific learning activities that are taking place simultaneously in all of the school's classrooms.

In its favor, teachers told the Free Press, Open Court has a very strong phonics emphasis. But teachers say that Open Court has no published research data showing any significant long term gains of the technique. Teachers are openly questioning textbook publishers' interference with the role of the classroom teacher in planning the public school's classroom learning activities.

Typical of the authoritarian dedication of some school administrators are the remarks of the former Sacramento Unified Schools administrator in charge of Open Court's program there. ``There's still a mentality, the idea that a teacher should be able to teach a class and make all the decisions,'' Sharon VanVleck told reporters.``But that was an ideal. It failed. I think we have to have a more systematic system.''

The over crowded 300,000-student Los Angeles Unified has also bought into the Open Court ideology for the past four years. It seemed to be the right thing to do. After all, The State School Board had included the Open Court publisher's textbooks among those approved for funding. Sacramento, Inglewood and Fremont, Fresno, Clovis all are using the program and Oakland has signed on for Fall 2000.

Now published by SRA/McGraw Hill, Open Court is a phonics-based reading and writing program for students in kindergarten through sixth grade. Most California school district curriculum specialists rejected it years ago. But in 1996 California legislators were pushing school district to use intensive phonics instruction as a way of dramatically improving reading test scores. The price tag was a mere $50 to $70 per student. What could they lose?

The Fremont School District quickly adopted the questionable textbooks in 1997 in grades Kindergarten through Third. Since then, Fremont First and Second Grade haves gained a few percentile points on District administered standardized reading tests. Sacramento Unified adopted the program two years ago and it has gained a few percentile points on its District administered reading tests.

These school districts, however, have not undertaken an independent statistical analysis on the Open Court publisher's real effectiveness as compared to tradition non-Open Court classrooms

The absence of independent educational research in California on the claims of the Open Court publisher's is revealing.

After years of experimentation by the California School Board in California schools the only report cited in the record is a flawed study of schools in which the Open Court and a literature-based program known as whole language were compared for test score results only. The study's authors, headed by prof. Barbara Forman of the University of Texa Houston, concluded that Open Court students ``had significantly higher scores'' than students in the other two types of programs. Yet, in stark contrast with that finding was the unexplained conclusion of the researcher that "spelling was comparable across the groups." Shaking Open Court's case to its foundation was the earth-moving finding that students taught in whole language ``had more positive attitudes toward reading.''


Letter to the Editor

©2000 Clovis Free Press. All rights reserved.

Front Page | Calendar | Datebook | Real Estate | Opinion | Search | E-mail | City Cam | Schools
Public Affairs | Trails | Conservancy | Wish List | Free Classifieds! | Masthead | Advertise | Marketplace

News Stand

Valley Press | Bulldog News | California Star | Clovis Free Press | Daily Republican
Fresno Republican | Tollhouse - Shaver | Tower2000 News | Yosemite News

Aluisi Real Estate | Archer's Music | Auto Accessories | Auto House | PC Paramedics
Presentations Inc.
| Reagan Library | Sierra Portal | Web Portal

Clovis Free Press

"Of the people ~ By the people ~ For the People" - A. Lincoln

Copyright 1962, 2004 by Clovis Free Press - ClovisNews.com
Contact: Editor@ClovisNews.com
All rights reserved. Disclaim
Accessibility Guidelines

[an error occurred while processing this directive]